Validation status is NOT execution permission
H1 — Astro/selective React/Node runtime proof in separate synthetic disposable project
- Id
- H1
- Title
- Astro/selective React/Node runtime proof in separate synthetic disposable project
- Dependencies
- H7 validation geography → actual publishing/cost/synthetic environment verification
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED TO RESUME
- Execution Status
- BLOCKED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- BLOCKED
- Evidence
- A–O report, ZIP, raw preflight
- Condition
- Required bounded runtime suitability only; no production readiness/product/next gate/freeze
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
H1 — Single bounded Astro/Replit runtime proof
Purpose: Prove the relevant execution assumptions without building the product.
Maximum functional scope: one synthetic prerendered public route, one small selective React island, one mock server POST endpoint, mock content and a synthetic server-only environment marker. No brand UI, real integrations, database, identity or operational features.
Required functional/security evidence:
- Record supported stable Astro, compatible Node adapter/runtime and reproducible build configuration.
- Clean build/start succeeds in the separately authorized Autoscale validation deployment; port/binding is correct.
- Public HTML contains mock content before JavaScript; content remains usable with JavaScript disabled.
- Only the intended island hydrates, works with keyboard/touch and has no hydration errors.
- Mock POST accepts valid bounded data, rejects malformed/oversized data and exposes controlled forced failures. Invalid requests never return acceptance success.
- Server reads the synthetic marker; no marker appears in HTML, browser bundles, responses or logs.
- Record representative headers on success/error responses; tested CSP allows required assets without weakening it simply to pass.
- Mock published content survives mock-source unavailability; a failed new-content build does not replace the working publication.
- Meet applicable JavaScript/accessibility requirements and capture asset sizes, statuses, headers, build/start logs and forced-error evidence.
Required measurement evidence:
- Use an appropriate repeated warm-route sample. Retain the initial minimum of 20 warm navigations as exploratory evidence, expand where needed for representative percentile conclusions, and state profile, sample size and limitations.
- Retain warm-route TTFB p95 ≤800 ms and mock POST p95 ≤1 s as acceptance benchmarks, with adequate sampling and documented methodology.
- Retain controlled navigation LCP ≤2.5 s at p75 and the applicable content-page JS budget. Lab proof does not establish production field Core Web Vitals.
- Record an initial set of at least 10 idle-to-request observations under a documented regional/mobile profile. For each, record result, preceding idle duration and available startup evidence.
- Distinguish confirmed observed cold starts, unconfirmed idle requests and merely slow requests.
- Report idle/cold median, maximum and distribution, separating meaningful cohorts. Do not infer a statistically meaningful p95 from ten observations.
- Treat idle/cold TTFB of 1.5 s as an initial target, not an automatic architectural failure threshold from this small sample.
Disposition:
- PASS: Required functional, security, failure-handling, accessibility, JS and LCP checks pass; measured runtime is suitable without material architectural problems. Recommend Astro technology ratification without unnecessary framework experimentation.
- PASS WITH ADJUSTMENT: Mandatory checks are not waived. Target-exceeding cold behaviour or a bounded deployment adjustment is assessed against user impact, public prerender behaviour, intake latency, frequency, deployment alternatives and cost. Record the adjustment and required confirming evidence; obtain approval before adopting it.
- FAIL: A material functional/security/quality failure or unacceptable measured user impact remains unresolved. Record reproduction and significance; propose a bounded fix/retest or an owner-approved fallback review. Do not automatically build Next.js in parallel.
If available evidence cannot establish required behaviour, record the limitation and keep the relevant conclusion unproven. Never label missing evidence as a pass.
Preserve accepted evidence independently before any authorized disposal of validation resources.
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H2 — CMS choice / publication
- Id
- H2
- Title
- CMS choice / publication
- Dependencies
- Approved isolated proof; editor/content contract; account API/quotas/cost/processor review
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Structured content/revisions/media/localization, protected draft/preview/publication, outage preservation, release traceability/media dependency; informs CMS choice, not implementation/publication
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H2 — CMS choice | Editor demonstrates structured content, revisions/media, localization readiness, draft isolation and protected preview. Publication works; temporary outage leaves published pages available. API/quotas, costs and processor terms meet requirements. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H3 — Journal / PostgreSQL / dispatch
- Id
- H3
- Title
- Journal / PostgreSQL / dispatch
- Dependencies
- Approved isolated proof; minimal atomic acceptance/intent contract; identity/privacy/access and pool/provider limits
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Commit-before-success, rollback/no false success, ambiguous commits, safe retry/dedup/concurrency, restart/republish persistence, atomic delivery intent and failure recovery, restricted inspection; informs journal/access design, not schema/CRM/product authority
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H3 — Journal/PostgreSQL | Later approved isolated proof demonstrates commit-before-success, rollback/no false success, persistence across restart/republish, safe retry/deduplication, atomic delivery intent and recovery of notification/handoff failures. Pool limits and restricted staff inspection are adequate; no CRM fields. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H4 — Transactional email
- Id
- H4
- Title
- Transactional email
- Dependencies
- Approved controlled proof; account/domain ownership and SPF/DKIM/DMARC; correlated journal-ID delivery contract
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Rejection/timeout/retry/bounce/duplicate-event visibility and recovery; email cannot invalidate committed acceptance; informs provider design, not setup/spend/guarantees
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H4 — Transactional email | Domain/account ownership and SPF/DKIM/DMARC reviewed. Controlled delivery correlates to journal IDs; rejection, timeout, retry, bounce and duplicate events are visible/recoverable. Email failure cannot invalidate committed acceptance. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H5 — Anti-abuse / shared enforcement
- Id
- H5
- Title
- Anti-abuse / shared enforcement
- Dependencies
- Approved bounded proof; payload/control policy; concurrent/replica-equivalent methodology
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Bounded payload/shared enforcement, legitimate/shared-network usability, safe logs and dependency-failure policy; no memory-only shared limiter; informs controls, not product exposure
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H5 — Anti-abuse | Bounded payloads and shared enforcement demonstrated under concurrent/replica-equivalent requests; legitimate/shared-network access remains usable. Logs are safe; no memory-only shared limiter. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H6 — Privacy-appropriate analytics
- Id
- H6
- Title
- Privacy-appropriate analytics
- Dependencies
- Approved events/processor/cost/privacy configuration and proof
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Actual requests exclude names/emails/free text/private project/artist data; accepted conversion follows durable acceptance; consent/blocker limits; analytics outside transaction, not acceptance truth or publication permission
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H6 — Analytics | Approved events, privacy/configuration and cost/processor review. Requests contain no names, emails, free text or private project/artist data. Acceptance corresponds to durable acceptance; reporting acknowledges consent/blocker gaps. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H7 — Validation geography North America approval; production is separate
- Id
- H7
- Title
- Validation geography North America approval; production is separate
- Dependencies
- Explicit validation Owner decision before H1; actual location remains unverified
- Authorization Status
- Historical limited approval reported; NO CURRENT EXECUTION
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- H1 report A/B/O + preserved prerequisite doc
- Condition
- Limited validation location decision only; not production H7 closure
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H7 — Geography | Validation: approve North America for the disposable Project or a material technical exception before H1 publishing; check location/permanence and any test resources. Production: separately approve intended North America or an evidence-backed exception; verify actual compute/database/storage, pre-created resources and external processors before first production publish. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H8 — Recovery / coordinated restore
- Id
- H8
- Title
- Recovery / coordinated restore
- Dependencies
- Actual plan/default-configured retention/available history; approved isolated restore/export; Owner-approved RPO/RTO
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- Documentary plan baseline only; no actual restore proof
- Condition
- Recovered inquiries/intent, usable export, application/database compatibility and safe replay; informs recovery reliance, not zero loss/default maximum/production acceptance
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H8 — Recovery | Verify actual account plan, configured/default retention and available history within documented plan limits. Approved isolated restore/export proves recovered inquiries and application/database compatibility. Approve RPO/RTO and coordinated code/database recovery before production reliance. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H9 — Secrets / staff access
- Id
- H9
- Title
- Secrets / staff access
- Dependencies
- Approved access inventory and synthetic exposure proof; accountable rotation/recovery owners
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- Historical existence-only preflight, not required access proof
- Condition
- Who views secrets or executes with them, MFA where available, scoped credentials, dev/production separation, exposure controls; not privilege grant or real-secret disclosure
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H9 — Secrets/staff access | Identify who can view secrets or execute code using them. Verify staff MFA where available, scoped credentials, dev/production separation and synthetic exposure checks. Assign rotation/recovery ownership. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H10 — CMS export / exit
- Id
- H10
- Title
- CMS export / exit
- Dependencies
- Approved representative content/metadata/media proof; permissions/account ownership/cost review
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- None of required proof supplied
- Condition
- Complete usable export/recovery/migration format, media references/files and limitations; informs portability, not selected CMS/frozen architecture
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H10 — CMS export/exit | Export representative content, metadata and media references/files; prove sufficient completeness and usable recovery/migration format. Record limitations, cost, permissions and account ownership. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
H11 — Storage boundaries if selected
- Id
- H11
- Title
- Storage boundaries if selected
- Dependencies
- Explicit justified App Storage selection and approved actual ownership/location/access/export proof
- Authorization Status
- NOT AUTHORIZED
- Execution Status
- UNEXECUTED
- Validation Status
- NOT DEMONSTRATED
- Artifact Status
- RATIFIED GATE DEFINITION — NOT PROOF
- Status
- VALIDATION REQUIRED
- Evidence
- Project-scoped documentary baseline only
- Condition
- Project ownership/dev-production/public-private boundaries, actual location/export/recovery, no venture sharing; N/A only if later justified without adoption, never automatic PASS
Purpose / prerequisites / evidence / actual result
| Gate | Exact required evidence |
|---|---|
| H11 — Storage boundaries | If App Storage is selected, verify project ownership, environment access, actual location and export/recovery against the current project-scoped baseline. Confirm no cross-venture sharing/dependency and appropriate public/private separation. |
Remaining uncertainty: required bounded proof is NOT DEMONSTRATED. PASS would establish applicable evidence only, not implementation, another gate, publication, phase progression or architecture freeze.
Risk register — recovery, ratified direction and architecture candidate
Risk register — recovery, ratified direction and architecture candidate
v1.3-RC — APPROVED PLANNING BASELINE. Original comprehensive historical review register is absent. REC-R IDs remain recovery/governance risks; T-R and AR retain provenance. Listed priority is not accepted residual risk. Owner adoption of eight planning contracts does not resolve technical risks without evidence; reserved acceptance remains staged. Material source/Book mismatch is BOOK_STALE → dependent execution STOP.
| ID | Risk | Priority / state | Evidence | Control / disposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| REC-R01 | Missing governing text causes invented product truth | ORIGINAL TEXT GAP RESOLVED; provenance/control risk remains | Three full sources restored/hash verified | Use exact source clauses; original referenced records still absent |
| REC-R02 | Candidate roadmap/book mistaken for ratification | HIGH / OPEN | Current document creation vs Owner review requirement | Visible candidate labels; no self-ratification |
| REC-R03 | Historical BLOCKED H1 mistaken for framework FAIL or PASS | HIGH / CONTROLLED IN CANDIDATE | H1 report O; Owner §2 | Preserve exact BLOCKED status; no runtime claims |
| REC-R04 | False authority from roadmap/Parent/Child or AI role | HIGH / OPEN | Owner §§3,14 | Verify cut/delegation; no automatic chaining or appointed Governor assumption |
| REC-R05 | Derived HTML/JSON drifts from Markdown | MEDIUM / OPEN | Owner §15 | Source hashes, generator, consistency audit; Markdown wins |
| REC-R06 | Evidence lost or overwritten during recovery | HIGH / CONTROLLED IN CANDIDATE | Existing H1 package | Byte-identical preservation; backup manifest/CRC/SHA256 |
| REC-R07 | Unrelated project material contaminates this book | HIGH / CONTROLLED IN CANDIDATE | Prior excluded attachment exists | Explicit source allowlist; no unrelated product import |
| REC-R08 | Backup/preview exposes secrets or internal governance publicly | HIGH / CONTROLLED IN CUT | Current no-publish/no-secret boundary | Copy allowlisted documentary sources only; no env dump; local Preview only, no publish |
| REC-R09 | Restoration confused with independent acceptance or validated configuration | HIGH / OPEN | Verified source bytes, candidate output, no runtime evidence | Separate source availability, authority, actual configuration and review |
Technical Direction I — retained risk deltas
Technical Direction I — retained risk deltas
| Source ID | Risk / priority | Control / remaining evidence |
|---|---|---|
| T-R01 | Scope inflation / HIGH | Prevent journal→CRM, curated proof→EPK and validation→product expansion |
| T-R02 | Positioning / MEDIUM residual | Ratified commercial lead; actual offer copy and Music routing approval |
| T-R04 | Lost inquiries / HIGH | H3/H4 durability, retry/delivery visibility and assigned staff follow-up |
| T-R05 | Rights/publication / HIGH | Accurate item relationship, asset/permission approval |
| T-R07 | Platform/vendor mismatch / HIGH | One isolated H1; candidates pending, no parallel framework experiment |
| T-R12 | Recovery / HIGH operational | Naming closure is not actual retention/history/restore/RPO/RTO proof |
| T-R17 | Lock-in / MEDIUM | H10 usable content/media export and no venture storage coupling |
| T-R22 | Irreversible geography / HIGH before publish | Separate validation/production H7; no future production publishing here |
| T-R23 | Platform drift / MEDIUM ongoing | Official-doc and actual-config rechecks at relevant later gates |
T-R21 documentary inconsistency: CLOSED / retired by the ratified Technical Direction, specifically App Storage cross-app and recovery naming disputes. This is a restored prior closure, not author acceptance of account/runtime risks. Preserve history; do not reopen it.
Architecture §20 — reconciled candidate risks
Architecture §20 — reconciled candidate risks
| Source ID / priority | Risk | Mitigation / gate and residual uncertainty |
|---|---|---|
| AR01 HIGH | Provisional framework/runtime unsuitable | Bounded H1; build/runtime/cold behaviour unproven |
| AR02 HIGH | CMS/draft/preview coupling exposes drafts or pages | Approved revisions/protected preview/retained release; H2/H9 assets/cache/promotion |
| AR03 HIGH | Lost/duplicate inquiry, orphan intent, false success | Atomic acceptance+outbox and identity; H3 concurrency/commit ambiguity |
| AR04 HIGH | Durable intent never dispatched after idle/restart | Recoverable trigger/staff inspection; H3/H4 activation/retry/cost ownership |
| AR05 HIGH | Replica-local state/DB connection exhaustion | Shared durable controls/bounded pooling; H3/H5 actual limits |
| AR06 HIGH | Journal grows into CRM/OS | Minimal concepts/truth/change control; Data review, follow-up pressure |
| AR07 HIGH | Unsupported/revoked claims persist publicly | Rights provenance/revision/corrective publication; H2/Brand, approved proof/removal |
| AR08 MEDIUM | Heavy media/scripts harm premium mobile UX | Budgets/selective hydration; H1/H6/Design final asset mix |
| AR09 HIGH | Provider outage/duplicate events corrupt handoff | Correlated durable attempts; H3/H4 provider idempotency/event semantics |
| AR10 MEDIUM | CMS lock-in/export gap | Stable contracts/representative export; H10 assets/revisions/cost |
| AR11 HIGH | Recovery overclaim/unsafe replay | Account and coordinated restore; H8 actual history/RPO/RTO/replay |
| AR12 HIGH before publish | Permanent unapproved location | Distinct H7 gates; actual resource/processors unknown |
| AR13 HIGH | No operating owner; failures unnoticed | Minimal staff process/backup/monitoring; named owners/targets/ceiling open |
| AR14 HIGH | Secret/private input leaks; ID enumeration/privacy | Separate contracts/logs/environment; no public lookup; H3/H6/H9/Security |
| AR15 HIGH for intake | Journal outage prevents confirmed acceptance | Editorial independence, controlled degraded mode/retry/fallback; H3/integrated boundary |
| AR16 HIGH for publication | Cannot identify approved public content/app/assets | Release-manifest traceability; H2/H10 tooling linkage/retention/reproducibility |
Constitution VII.3/XIV/XV governs material exceptions and residual HIGH/CRITICAL risk acceptance. Missing mandatory evidence cannot be hidden behind PASS WITH GAPS. No risk is independently accepted by authoring this register.
Prior H1 blocker is retained, not treated as evidence of unacceptable Astro behavior. No full security model or original residual-risk acceptance is inferred here.
Validation register — H1–H11
Validation register — H1–H11
Current H1 autonomous-window prerequisite disposition
Current H1 autonomous-window prerequisite disposition
H1.LOCAL.PREPARE.2026-10-04 / PH0.VAL.C01: BLOCKED — VALID PREREQUISITE STOP, neither H1 PASS nor FAIL. Exact local synthetic fixture now has 45 passing author checks, not published gate acceptance. Screenshot corroborates Autoscale/max3, not required max1; credits unverified. Owner approves USD 5 total, included credits only, no extra charges. Required published warm/POST/idle observations remain 0/0/0. H2–H11 UNEXECUTED; full H7, separate review and formal Child closure not claimed. Owner requests PH1–PH3/Governor progression, but dependencies and role activation remain unmet. Evidence: evidence/phase-0-autonomous-window/h1-local/; prior evidence unchanged.
v1.1-RC — REVIEW CANDIDATE. Sources: restored Technical Direction H/B; Architecture §§18/23; Constitution IX; current Owner §§10/18; historical H1 A–O report.
Historical H1 requirements and missing observations
Historical H1 requirements and missing observations
Preserved historical benchmarks: ≥20 warm route samples, adequate POST samples, route p95 ≤800 ms, POST p95 ≤1 s, ≥10 idle-to-request observations with actual idle/startup classification, no meaningful cold p95 from ten, LCP ≤2.5 s p75 where meaningful, initial content JS ≤100 KB compressed.
Report retains functional/security/runtime/no-JS/island/POST/error/secret/header/publication-resilience/accessibility requirements. Actual warm/POST/idle observations: 0 / 0 / 0. These criteria were not run or waived.
Restored H1 contract definition — not a resumed cut
Restored H1 contract definition — not a resumed cut
Technical Direction H1 governs the full future proof: one synthetic prerendered route, one small selective React island, one mock bounded POST, mock content and a synthetic server-only marker, separate disposable Project; no brand/product UI, real integrations, database, company/artist/client data or production credentials/CMS/domain.
- Supported stable Astro and compatible Node adapter/runtime with reproducible config; clean authorized Autoscale build/start and correct binding/port.
- Mock HTML readable before/without JS; only intended island hydrates, keyboard/touch works, no hydration errors.
- POST accepts valid bounded input, rejects malformed/oversized input and demonstrates controlled forced failures; invalid input never acceptance success.
- Synthetic marker server-readable but absent from HTML/bundles/responses/logs.
- Representative success/error headers; tested CSP allows required assets without weakening simply to pass.
- Mock approved publication survives source outage; failed new-content build does not replace working publication.
- Applicable accessibility/JS/LCP checks, asset sizes/statuses/headers/build/start/forced-error evidence.
- Warm route minimum 20 exploratory navigations, expanded as needed for adequate p95; route p95 ≤800 ms, POST p95 ≤1 s, controlled LCP ≤2.5 s p75, content JS budget. State profile/sample/limits; lab does not prove field CWV.
- At least 10 initial idle-to-request observations with per-result idle duration/startup evidence. Distinguish confirmed cold starts, unconfirmed idle requests and slow requests; report meaningful-cohort median/maximum/distribution. 1.5 s is initial target, not automatic tiny-sample FAIL; no statistically meaningful p95 from ten.
PASS: mandatory functional/security/failure/accessibility/JS/LCP checks pass, runtime suitable without material problems; recommend—not self-issue—technology ratification.
PASS WITH ADJUSTMENT: no mandatory waiver; assess target-exceeding cold/deployment behaviour by user impact, prerender/intake latency, frequency, alternatives and cost; record approved adjustment and required confirming evidence before adoption.
FAIL: unresolved material functional/security/quality failure or unacceptable measured user impact; preserve reproduction; propose bounded fix/retest or Owner-approved fallback review, never automatic parallel Next.js.
Insufficient evidence keeps the conclusion unproven/BLOCKED. Preserve accepted evidence independently before any separately authorized disposal. Current H1 is BLOCKED — VALID PREREQUISITE STOP, NOT PASS, NOT FAIL, NOT Astro rejection, NOT Replit rejection; runtime NOT DEMONSTRATED.
H1 blockers: no observable actual region/mode/cost or synthetic-only secret provenance; publishing requires user action. This is recorded control-access limitation, not proof of framework failure.
No empirical deployment secret synchronization, actual deployed retention, browser behavior, region/performance or CMS controls were demonstrated. Do not rerun checks under this recovery cut.
Evidence index
Evidence index
Current Phase 0 autonomous-window preflight
Current Phase 0 autonomous-window preflight
Latest continuation evidence: evidence/phase-0-autonomous-window/H1-LOCAL-PREPARATION-CONTRACT.md, OWNER-CONTINUATION-2026-10-04.md, OWNER-CONFIGURATION-PARTIAL-2026-10-04.md and h1-local/local-results.json, build/start log and local mobile screenshot. Fixture-local lock and exact sources are at scripts/validation/h1/. 45 local checks, not published H1 acceptance; published counts 0/0/0; author review only. Earlier debugging failures are retained, not silently erased. Prior preflight Book/source/recipe evidence is preserved at historical/h1-preflight-before-local-preparation/.
evidence/phase-0-autonomous-window/: exact latest Owner authority, local identity/Book observations, platform unpublished/secret-existence-only metadata, official documentation provenance, H1 BLOCKED disposition, protected history fingerprints and current derived freshness. No runtime acceptance or independent review claimed. historical/ratified-current-before-autonomous-window/ preserves prior current editions/recipes/ZIPs. Original H1, RC, ratification and consistency-reissue evidence remain immutable.
Current official Book documentary evidence
Current official Book documentary evidence
- Owner Planning Disposition S07: explicit Owner report of Governor-assisted independent review and PASS WITH CONDITIONS adoption, not an independently produced review by this author. Separate review transcript/identity not supplied.
evidence/master-book/baseline.json: 123 pre-Book documentary/source/output hashes, not whole-repository forensic capture.evidence/master-book/self-audit.json: author source/section/contract/state/staleness/link/integrity checks; not technical gate or independent acceptance.master-book/book-manifest.json,master-book/book-integrity.sha256: source/output hashes and canonical freshness contract.evidence/master-book/: desktop/mobile observations, print/PDF observations and authoring report; final paths/counts/checks recorded after generation.- Prior v1.2-RC package remains historical and unchanged; new v1.3-RC Book backup preserves it alongside v1.1-RC and the first backup.
v1.2-RC — MASTER PLANNING CANDIDATE evidence index. Integrity, authority and acceptance are distinct.
Current master planning evidence
Current master planning evidence
| Record | Path | What it establishes / limits |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-planning hashes | evidence/master-planning/baseline.json | 101 captured existing documentary/source/preview file hashes before new candidate writes; not a whole-repository forensic snapshot |
| Current input inventory | evidence/master-planning/source-inventory.json | Original Owner/full-source/historical input hashes; immutable source bytes |
| Requirements coverage | evidence/master-planning/REQUIREMENTS_COVERAGE.md | Owner §4–16 and downstream clause-to-artifact contract map; author analysis, not acceptance |
| Author self-audit | evidence/master-planning/self-audit.json | Actual deterministic field/reference/graph/source/mirror/status checks; not independent review, runtime proof or brand ratification |
| Local static screenshots | evidence/master-planning/control-room-desktop.jpg and control-room-mobile.jpg | Desktop/mobile visible document state; not a public product or interactive-flow/security proof |
| Completion report | evidence/master-planning/MASTER_PLANNING_COMPLETION_REPORT.md | Candidate summaries/counts/readiness/decision windows/limitations and final review STOP |
| New manifest/backup | deliverables/project-brain-v1.2-RC-manifest.json and studio-333-project-brain-v1.2-RC-backup.zip/.sha256 | Allowlisted reconstructed payload with CRC/per-file integrity; both historical backups preserved |
| Final return report | deliverables/studio-333-master-planning-completion-report.html | Self-contained readable report with final backup SHA256 outside ZIP to avoid circular hashes |
Prior restoration/recovery/H1 records below remain historical and unchanged; they are not current cut authority or new gate results.
| Evidence | Location | Classification / acceptance |
|---|---|---|
| Previous recovery authorization | Owner attachment in Source Index S01 | Historical documentary cut; consumed on delivery |
| Identical recovery attachment | Source Index S02 | Byte-identical duplicate, not a competing decision |
| Historical H1 A–O report | evidence/h1-blocked-2026-10-03/REPORT-A-O.md | Agent-produced evidence; Owner now confirms valid BLOCKED stop; no implied independent review |
| H1 package | evidence/H1-BLOCKED-2026-10-03.zip | Preserved unchanged; integrity checked, not runtime PASS |
| Raw deployment/artifact/secret-existence checks | evidence/h1-blocked-2026-10-03/raw/preflight.json | Historical observed API responses; no secret values |
| Version and callback record | H1 raw/ directory | Historical registry/runtime/read-only commands |
| Official documentation fetches | H1 docs/1-… through 5-… | Historical documentation, not account/runtime evidence |
| Owner-supplied prerequisite record | H1 docs/owner-prerequisite-record.md | Origin-attributed documentation prerequisite record |
| Source inventory / hashes | evidence/project-recovery/source-inventory.json | Current allowlisted local surviving-file observations |
| Recovery consistency audit | evidence/project-recovery/self-audit.json | Author self-check; not independent acceptance |
| Control Room screenshots | evidence/project-recovery/control-room-desktop.jpg, control-room-mobile.jpg | Local static-view visual evidence only, no deployment claim |
| Backup integrity | deliverables/studio-333-project-brain-backup.sha256 + project-brain-manifest.json | Documentary preservation; not ratification |
Evidence acceptance is separate from byte integrity. The original comprehensive evidence index and accepted review records are missing. Do not represent this newly authored index as proof that all prior requirements are evidenced.
Current restoration evidence
Current restoration evidence
| Evidence | Location | Classification / limits |
|---|---|---|
| Current explicit Owner instruction | S03 in Source Index | Restoration/reconciliation/handoff scope only; STOP on delivery |
| Original recovery pack and manifest | S04; evidence/project-reconciliation/source-pack | Manifest covers three governing docs and README; all hashes/lengths and CRC checked |
| Three restored full sources | reports/ canonical filenames in Source Index | Exact-byte governing texts/issuance records; not newly ratified or runtime-tested |
| Source verification | evidence/project-reconciliation/source-verification.json | Pack/source SHA256, lengths, before-write conflict checks and original backup preservation |
| Pre-change documentary inventory | evidence/project-reconciliation/pre-reconciliation-files.json | Baseline hashes; initial restore script itself was newly authored before capture |
| Clause correction / requirement map and report | evidence/project-reconciliation/RECONCILIATION_REPORT.md | Author documentary analysis and coverage; not independent acceptance |
| Historical recovery consistency audit | evidence/project-reconciliation/self-audit.json | Author documentary checks at that earlier cut; not current local H1 or production proof |
| Current local screenshots | evidence/project-reconciliation/control-room-desktop.jpg and control-room-mobile.jpg | Static governance/documentary visual evidence; not publication |
| New manifest/backup/sidecar | deliverables/project-brain-v1.1-RC-manifest.json and studio-333-project-brain-v1.1-RC-backup.zip/.sha256 | Restored sources and review candidate with per-payload integrity |
Old evidence/project-recovery outputs and prior v1.0-RC backup remain historical, unchanged. Source texts report original independent-review/ratification context; absent separately referenced inputs are not fabricated or represented as newly inspected.